Difference between revisions of "CSIT/Meeting"

From fd.io
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(26 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 31: Line 31:
 
== Agenda ==
 
== Agenda ==
  
−
The next CSIT meeting is scheduled for Wednesday 14-August 15:00-16:00 London time / 07:00-08:00 PST. Proposed topics:
+
The next CSIT meeting is scheduled for Wednesday 27-November 15:00-16:00 London time / 07:00-08:00 PST. Proposed topics:
  
 
# #startmeeting "FD.io CSIT Project Meeting"
 
# #startmeeting "FD.io CSIT Project Meeting"
−
# #chair dwallacelf jlinkes Kai98 vrpolak mackonstan tifrank
+
# #chair dwallacelf Kai98 vrpolak mackonstan tifrank
 
# #topic Agenda bashing
 
# #topic Agenda bashing
 
# #topic VPP update
 
# #topic VPP update
Line 43: Line 43:
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SPR QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVkFuwyAQfI17qVYCYupcemjqf0QYtjFqjDdAU7mvL3Gj4lwaVYl88gUkZndntKORCLH3uA24fy7kpqg2haisSUexenlM15EIVq6BQB44YzsUxHHNmT6AIfMO2g8Ue-CSrxvgGjC2lkpLAXUqZyy6ffupwuA0pPdGBQTrIigMQj7tdAed9yc28XpiMx_xgjoj1A4Z-UNQ7lAeVW750ZnRiGFC9V_Vec6bVx0G-4V52LiLXKHTfiegvtQQB5qg52VU9VgxvxlkFjN-0fMy7mKGWJJxzQwxWzLEkozbzLhnMsolGdfMKGdLRrkk4zYzcjJk_eB6342_Kll_A09FsIY trending results]
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SPR QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVkFuwyAQfI17qVYCYupcemjqf0QYtjFqjDdAU7mvL3Gj4lwaVYl88gUkZndntKORCLH3uA24fy7kpqg2haisSUexenlM15EIVq6BQB44YzsUxHHNmT6AIfMO2g8Ue-CSrxvgGjC2lkpLAXUqZyy6ffupwuA0pPdGBQTrIigMQj7tdAed9yc28XpiMx_xgjoj1A4Z-UNQ7lAeVW750ZnRiGFC9V_Vec6bVx0G-4V52LiLXKHTfiegvtQQB5qg52VU9VgxvxlkFjN-0fMy7mKGWJJxzQwxWzLEkozbzLhnMsolGdfMKGdLRrkk4zYzcjJk_eB6342_Kll_A09FsIY trending results]
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SNR QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVkFuwyAQfI17qVYqG1Pn0kNT_yMisI1RY7wBmsp9fYlrCefQSFUin8wBJGbZWc1oJELsPG0DHV4KuSmqTYGVNWkrVq-P6Tgxw8pBcB5Q7glZ0BpRH8Gw-QDte44dCCnWOxAaKDaWS8uBtHhKK7pD86VC7zSk-50KBNZFUBRQPu91C633Zy58O3OZz3hBnBFu-oz8OU6uV55UfvA7ZUYjhQnRf2fOfd69ainYb8rNBiVyhU7aTkB9OUPseYKOUlT1UDG3EWwWI0Z0lOIORuCSiOtG4EyJwCURtxhxv0SUSyKuG1HOlIhyScQtRuREyPrBdb4dfk-y_gG2TqoC trending results]
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SNR QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVkFuwyAQfI17qVYqG1Pn0kNT_yMisI1RY7wBmsp9fYlrCefQSFUin8wBJGbZWc1oJELsPG0DHV4KuSmqTYGVNWkrVq-P6Tgxw8pBcB5Q7glZ0BpRH8Gw-QDte44dCCnWOxAaKDaWS8uBtHhKK7pD86VC7zSk-50KBNZFUBRQPu91C633Zy58O3OZz3hBnBFu-oz8OU6uV55UfvA7ZUYjhQnRf2fOfd69ainYb8rNBiVyhU7aTkB9OUPseYKOUlT1UDG3EWwWI0Z0lOIORuCSiOtG4EyJwCURtxhxv0SUSyKuG1HOlIhyScQtRuREyPrBdb4dfk-y_gG2TqoC trending results]
−
#* #topic HW accelerator - ICXD QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtlEFuwjAQRU8TNmgk7MQNmy6A3AOZ8UCsEmdku4Vw-pq0ksMC1KpSV3hhS_7j-V_zJIfYe9oGOr4Wal3U60LW1qStKFfzdHwwQ-nA4tmAVAeSLGgpSwTD5g3QDxx7EEosdyAQKLaWK8uBUCzSiu7YnnQYHEK63-lAYF0ETUGqlwN20Hl_9ZKbq5d5jzfGWeF2yMrdOLlee9L5wVfKrEYKE6PfZs599l53FOyFcrNxErkC02wnIt5miANP1O9R1M1Y8RcQ8gniMQj5TyCqJ4jHIKofglDNzPW-G78o1XwC3stYbg trending results]
+
#* #topic HW accelerator - ICXD QAT2.0 - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtlkFOwzAQRU8TNmgk7MSkGxa0vUfl2kNjkTiWx9Cmp8cJlZwuiECIsnEWTuQ_8Yz-k75Mofe4I2yfCrEu6nXBa6PjUpTP9_H17hyUFow6aeDigNwxXPFSgXb6FZQfXOiBCbbaA1OAoTGuMo5QsYf4BNs2R0mDVRD395IQjA0gkbh4PKgOOu_HXnwz9tJv4apxUlwzJOXLcVK99CjTD59TJjUgzRr9dOZ0zouXHZI5YzpsciJVqOjtTFTXM4TBzdSLFfV2qvgNCJ5BLIPgNwJRZRDLIKo_B2E6c8rJNDoXjfi_YJow5FxaxsBvgyGn0jKG74aS2N7Z3nfTvSl-U9MfIXgjW7psfQD6wbI- trending results]
 +
#* #topic GTPU HW - [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrdVNtugzAM_Rr2MlkitJS97GEd_1GF4JVoXNw4tHRf34CmmUplj53Wl1x8fHzsoyjsO4c7xvo1SrdRto2SzJZhiVZvz2E7EsGqBWsGUHG8x4QUvqjYHKCk8hMsrXe-b1usGTbrApQB9FWI7j311WnEC80IjXNjzeR9rFn2_kpAEKrOgizLCkE71MKYdSMpHnkmd6s7yf1wukG2XyiEMJXgJnglkDLXKv5MM_R75CyfMn4zNkl_BhyG492MvSH7OMYWwOT-4Mku6j6atfd_tIu6_8zaNH9qO9dM_204c9WdwDura55CgTxdxuw0vwA7i5e4 trending currently empty as test always fails]
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SPR DSA
 
#* #topic HW accelerator - SPR DSA
 
#** vpp l2bd memif 1core results with-DSA vs without-DSA:
 
#** vpp l2bd memif 1core results with-DSA vs without-DSA:
Line 50: Line 51:
 
#** New link with NGINX+DSA trending:
 
#** New link with NGINX+DSA trending:
 
#*** [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVcFOwzAM_ZpyQZaSsKq7cGDsP6osMUu0tjGx2RhfT1cmsgkhIU2CA7skUZ7t5zw7MkvK2DJ291W9qJpFZZrox6W6e7gdty0RmAGYMmil1mhI41wr9wye_AZCYmGxbgNqBdoBSoBIM3EURAh8b6HzlLFL1sOwjsMr6NbotoZMfGAxjwcW_yJnlAWhsC_I94kUB5vRFo_P_IqBIJ-Q_TjhEuAp2x45vmGJolYFdqOeBdHunFn2dIIeRWiWk8VF4pur-F_EN78ivlGz-X9u_un9f9v_HyUw1xJc8gvq5c2Qcj_NgfHMIe1AcrQdH6_eAe05xSU RPS tests up to 35 Gbps]
 
#*** [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtVcFOwzAM_ZpyQZaSsKq7cGDsP6osMUu0tjGx2RhfT1cmsgkhIU2CA7skUZ7t5zw7MkvK2DJ291W9qJpFZZrox6W6e7gdty0RmAGYMmil1mhI41wr9wye_AZCYmGxbgNqBdoBSoBIM3EURAh8b6HzlLFL1sOwjsMr6NbotoZMfGAxjwcW_yJnlAWhsC_I94kUB5vRFo_P_IqBIJ-Q_TjhEuAp2x45vmGJolYFdqOeBdHunFn2dIIeRWiWk8VF4pur-F_EN78ivlGz-X9u_un9f9v_HyUw1xJc8gvq5c2Qcj_NgfHMIe1AcrQdH6_eAe05xSU RPS tests up to 35 Gbps]
−
# [https://wiki.fd.io/view/CSIT/csit2406_plan #topic CSIT-2406 release]
+
#** NGINX 2c tests have two-band structure and DSA is more likely to have worse performance:
 +
#*** [https://csit.fd.io/trending/#eNrtlMFqwzAMhp8mvQxB7DXktMO6vkdwba02c2JhaW3ap29aytxSGD0MRtkuttEv6RcfwiwpY8cYX6pmUbWLSrfBTUf1_Po0XRsi0AMwZdB1vUZNyo7tBo1AH8cGfGJhMfYD6hUoCygeAs3FkhchcL2B6ChjTMbBsA7DCKrTqmvAEh9t9NvRxn3KlWdRyO-K8s0kpcJkNKXka8CSIMgXbndPXBq8Z9Mjhz2WLvWqyHYiWhRlr51lRxfqmUK7PGX8NP7HQv-g2PX_1t_i17-I_w9v_b3Ym-VsSLk__fnTm33aguRgIp9DB0_Uw1k trending]
 +
#*** [https://jira.fd.io/browse/CSIT-1971 Jira CSIT-1971]
 +
# #topic CSIT-2410 release notes and VPP RCAs
 +
#* [https://lists.fd.io/g/csit-dev/message/4758 Link to announce email]
 +
#* [https://csit.fd.io/cdocs/release_notes/current/ Release Report]
 +
#* [https://csit.fd.io/cdocs/release_notes/current/vpp_performance/ CSIT 24.10 - VPP Performance]
 +
# [https://wiki.fd.io/view/CSIT/csit2410_plan #topic CSIT-2502 release plan]
 
# #topic Physical Infrastructure
 
# #topic Physical Infrastructure
−
#* [https://github.com/FDio/csit/blob/master/docs/lab/testbed_specifications.md Performance testing]: Intel Xeon CLX/ICX/SPR, Arm TX2/TSH/ALT, Intel Atom, AMD Zen2.
+
#* [https://github.com/FDio/csit/blob/master/docs/lab/testbed_specifications.md Performance testing]: Intel Xeon ICX/SPR, Arm ALT/OCT, Nvidia GRS, Intel SNR/ICXD, AMD Zen2.
−
#* [https://github.com/FDio/csit/blob/master/docs/lab/testbed_specifications.md Functional driver testing]: Intel Xeon SKX, Arm TX2.
+
#* [https://github.com/FDio/csit/blob/master/docs/lab/testbed_specifications.md Functional driver testing]: Intel Xeon SPR, Arm ALT.
 
#* [https://wiki.fd.io/view/Infrastructure_Support Updated LFN FD.io infra support documentation].
 
#* [https://wiki.fd.io/view/Infrastructure_Support Updated LFN FD.io infra support documentation].
 
#* Lab extension points
 
#* Lab extension points
Line 60: Line 68:
 
#** Marvell Octeon10 DPU (processors based on Arm Neoverse N2 uarch)
 
#** Marvell Octeon10 DPU (processors based on Arm Neoverse N2 uarch)
 
#** AMD Zen-4 server(s), most likely with Genoa processors (fully fledged Zen4 cores)
 
#** AMD Zen-4 server(s), most likely with Genoa processors (fully fledged Zen4 cores)
 +
#* Lab equipment decommissioning
 +
#** Arm TX2, Arm TSH, Intel XEON CLX - donation status.
 +
#* CSIT mirror in Netgate labs (Neil)
 
# #topic Virtual Infrastructure, CI/CD
 
# #topic Virtual Infrastructure, CI/CD
 
#* LFN FD.io CI/CD systems.
 
#* LFN FD.io CI/CD systems.
−
#* Jenkins jobs: csit-vpp, vpp-csit.
+
#* Jenkins -> Github Actions migration (selected jobs only)
−
#* vpp-csit jobs: vpp-csit-verify-device-{..}-tx2, vpp-csit-verify-device-{..}-spr
+
#* Jira -> Github Issues migration
−
#** status of addressing intermittent failures not related to vpp patch code changes
+
 
# #topic Environment, Framework
 
# #topic Environment, Framework
 +
#* TRex + e810 DPDK compatibility
 
#* VPP API tracking.
 
#* VPP API tracking.
 
#** RSS keys.
 
#** RSS keys.
 
#** CLI without API.
 
#** CLI without API.
 +
#** Experimental/Production/Deprecated APIs.
 
# #topic Trending and Test Failures
 
# #topic Trending and Test Failures
 
#* [https://wiki.fd.io/view/CSIT/TestFailuresTracking CSIT Test Failures Tracking Wiki]
 
#* [https://wiki.fd.io/view/CSIT/TestFailuresTracking CSIT Test Failures Tracking Wiki]
Line 76: Line 88:
 
#** [http://csit.fd.io/stats/ Test Job Statistics]
 
#** [http://csit.fd.io/stats/ Test Job Statistics]
 
#** [http://csit.fd.io/news/ Failures and Anomalies]
 
#** [http://csit.fd.io/news/ Failures and Anomalies]
−
# #topic Analytics, Presentation.
+
# #topic Analytics, Presentation.  
−
#* Old release results in CSIT-Dash:
+
−
#** Latest releace available in pre-CDash PAL was [https://docs.fd.io/csit/master/report/ rls2302]
+
−
#** Original CDash rule: Only process the latest + 2 earlier releases.
+
−
#** Currently inaccessible results: rls2306.
+
−
#** First CDash-ready data is from rls2302.
+
−
#** Some data from rls2210 could be accessible, but not complete.
+
−
#** Vote: Make all releases from rls2302 on available in CDash?
+
−
#** Applying "all releases rule" (and to keep up with the trajectory 3rls/year for several upcoming years) requires larger instances (C7*/R7* optimised).
+
−
This will double the monthly/yearly costs short term, while keep the risk of going to 3* the today's costs in long term.
+
−
Currently the C-Dash costs ~250$/month (~3000/year).
+
−
CSIT (including weekly, releases, testing and C-Dash) is ~350$/month (~5000$/year).
+
−
Forecast prediction (no change on instances) is ~419$/month for the next year (till Aug-2025). So effectively with the new C-Dash instances the rough estimate is 8000$ for a year for CSIT (that is +3000$).
+
−
Consider business justification before voting.  
+
 
# #topic Fd.io Events
 
# #topic Fd.io Events
 
#* [https://teamup.com/ksgw6qzqcmg9zbzsfq teamup Event calendar and Zoom links]
 
#* [https://teamup.com/ksgw6qzqcmg9zbzsfq teamup Event calendar and Zoom links]
 
# #topic Housekeeping
 
# #topic Housekeeping
 +
#* Jira references in CSIT code. Example: 41771: feat(TrafficGenerator): Retry one negative trial | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41771
 +
#* What to do when Json export validation fails:
 +
#** [https://jira.fd.io/browse/CSIT-1970 Jira CSIT-1970]
 +
#** Possible fix: 41765: fix(export): Fail and re-export on invalid pass | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41765
 
#* #link 41191: feat(guidelines): Add license and copyright | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41191
 
#* #link 41191: feat(guidelines): Add license and copyright | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41191
 
#* #link 41077: fix(guidelines): Apply low-controversy edits | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41077
 
#* #link 41077: fix(guidelines): Apply low-controversy edits | https://gerrit.fd.io/r/c/csit/+/41077

Latest revision as of 22:08, 20 November 2024

Meeting Details

Weekly on Wednesday 15:00 Greenwich, London time. FD.io Zoom Meeting room (passcode <remove spaces> '4 1 2 3 2 4')
If no DST in Europe and US: 07:00 PST, 10:00 EST, 15:00 UTC, 15:00 UK/GMT, 16:00 CET, 17:00 Israel Std Time, 20:30 India Std Time, 23:00 China Std Time.
If DST in Europe: 07:00 PDT, 10:00 EDT, 14:00 UTC, 15:00 UK/BST, 16:00 CEST, 17:00 Israel Summer Time, 19:30 India Std Time, 22:00 China Std Time.
If no DST in Europe and DST in US: 08:00 PDT, 11:00 EDT, 15:00 UTC, 15:00 UK/GMT, 16:00 CET, 17:00 Israel Std Time, 20:30 India Std Time, 23:00 China Std Time.

Topic: FD.io CSIT Project Meeting

Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android: https://zoom.us/my/fastdata?pwd=Z3Z0UnJyUmRIMlU3eTJLcGF6VEptQT09

Or iPhone one-tap (US Toll):  +14086380968,,5301185804# or +16465588656,,5301185804#

Or Telephone:
    Dial: +1 408 638 0968 (US Toll) or +1 646 558 8656 (US Toll)
    +1 855 880 1246 (US Toll Free)
    +1 877 369 0926 (US Toll Free)
    Meeting ID: 530 118 5804
    International numbers available: https://zoom.us/zoomconference?m=ppBOQMQTVxGYmbxNsVemC6KNo8eX2ptF

Issues connecting to the meeting? Contact: Maciek Konstantynowicz <mkonstan@cisco.com>.

Agenda

The next CSIT meeting is scheduled for Wednesday 27-November 15:00-16:00 London time / 07:00-08:00 PST. Proposed topics:

  1. #startmeeting "FD.io CSIT Project Meeting"
  2. #chair dwallacelf Kai98 vrpolak mackonstan tifrank
  3. #topic Agenda bashing
  4. #topic VPP update
  5. #topic TSC update
  6. #topic Other update
  7. #topic New or refactored tests
  8. VPP and CSIT (not so hot) items
  9. #topic CSIT-2410 release notes and VPP RCAs
  10. #topic CSIT-2502 release plan
  11. #topic Physical Infrastructure
    • Performance testing: Intel Xeon ICX/SPR, Arm ALT/OCT, Nvidia GRS, Intel SNR/ICXD, AMD Zen2.
    • Functional driver testing: Intel Xeon SPR, Arm ALT.
    • Updated LFN FD.io infra support documentation.
    • Lab extension points
      • SuperMicro servers with Intel Xeon EMR for SUTs (8568Y+ 48c 2.3GHz 350W 300MB DSA QAT) andTGs (8580 60c 2GHz 350W 300MB)
      • Nvidia Grace-Grace single socket super-server (processors based on Arm Neoverse V2 uarch)
      • Marvell Octeon10 DPU (processors based on Arm Neoverse N2 uarch)
      • AMD Zen-4 server(s), most likely with Genoa processors (fully fledged Zen4 cores)
    • Lab equipment decommissioning
      • Arm TX2, Arm TSH, Intel XEON CLX - donation status.
    • CSIT mirror in Netgate labs (Neil)
  12. #topic Virtual Infrastructure, CI/CD
    • LFN FD.io CI/CD systems.
    • Jenkins -> Github Actions migration (selected jobs only)
    • Jira -> Github Issues migration
  13. #topic Environment, Framework
    • TRex + e810 DPDK compatibility
    • VPP API tracking.
      • RSS keys.
      • CLI without API.
      • Experimental/Production/Deprecated APIs.
  14. #topic Trending and Test Failures
  15. #topic Analytics, Presentation.
  16. #topic Fd.io Events
  17. #topic Housekeeping
  18. #endmeeting

Meeting Minutes

Retrieved from "https://wiki.fd.io/index.php?title=CSIT/Meeting&oldid=12773"